One way to learn a new technology is to compare it to what you already know. I’ve heard a lot about Istio, and I don’t really grok it yet, so this post is my attempt to get the ideas solid in my own head, and to spur conversations out there.
I asked the great Google “Why is Istio important” and this was the most interesting response it gave me: “What is Istio and Its Importance to Container Security.” So I am going to start there. There are obviously many articles about Istio, and this might not even be the best starting point, but this is the internet: I’m sure Ill be told why something else is better!
Lets start with the definition:
Istio is an intelligent and robust web proxy for traffic within your Kubernetes cluster as well as incoming traffic to your cluster
At first blush, these seems to be nothing like Keystone. However, Lets take a look at the software definition of Proxy:
A proxy, in its most general form, is a class functioning as an interface to something else.
In the OpenStack code base, the package python-keystonemiddleware provides a Python class that complies with the WSGI contract that serves as a Proxy to the we application underneath. Keystone Middleware, then is an analogue to the Istio Proxy in that it performs some of the same functions.
Istio enables you to specify access control rules for web traffic between Kubernetes services
So…Keystone + Oslo-policy serves this role in OpenStack. The Kubernetes central control is a single web server, and thus it can implement Access control for all subcomponenets in a single process space. OpenStack is distributed, and thus the access control is also distributed. However, due to the way that OpenStack objects are stored, we cannot do the full RBAC enforcement in middleware (much as I would like to). IN order to check access to an existing resource object in OpenStack, you have to perform the policy enforcement check after the object has been fetched from the Database. That check needs to ensure that the project of the token matches the project of the resource. Since we don’t know this information based solely on the URL, we cannot perform it in Middleware.
What we can perform in Middleware, and what I presented on last year at the OpenStack Summit, is the ability to perform the Role check portion of RBAC in middleware, but defer the project check until later. While we are not going to be doing exactly that, we are pursuing a related effort for application credentials. However, that requires a remote call to a database to create those rules. Istio is not going to have that leeway. I think? Please correct me if I am wrong.
I don’t think Istio could perform this level of deep check, either. It requires parsing the URL and knowing the semantics of the segments, and having the ability to correlate them. That is a lot to ask.
Isito enables you to seamlessly enforce encryption and authentication between node
Keystone certainly does not do this. Nothing enforced TLS between services in OpenStack. Getting TLS everywhere in Tripleo was a huge effort, and it still needs to be explicitly enabled. OpenStack does not provide a CA. Tripleo, when deployed, depends on the Dogtag instance from the FreeIPA server to manage certificates.
By the time Keystone Middleware is executed, the TLS layer would be a distant memory.
Keystoneauth1 is the client piece from Keystone, and it could be responsible for making sure that only HTTPS is supported, but it does not do that today.
Istio collects traffic logs, and then parses and presents them for you:
Keystone does not do this, although it does produce some essential log entries about access.
At this point, I am wondering if Istio would be a viable complement to the security story in OpenStack. My understand thus far is that it would. It might conflict a minor bit with the RBAC enforcement, but I suspect that is no the key piece of what it is doing, and conflict there could be avoided.
Please post your comments, as I would really like to get to know this better, and we can share the discussion with the larger community.
Source From: fedoraplanet.org.
Original article title: Adam Young: Comparing Istio and Keystone Middleware.
This full article can be read at: Adam Young: Comparing Istio and Keystone Middleware.